An old college pal has shifted cities and since I'm an old Bangalore hand compared to her, I'm helping her settle in by pointing out all the right malls and rivergrass chatai shops. Old pal has an another old pal who is soon to be shifting permanently from US in what they call R2I in NRI and ex-NRI lingo, and as a consequence, all of us have been on Skype and Google Talk a lot. To my utter (inital) dismay and constant amusement, I have discovered the label that these lovely souls have had me stuck with for the last nine years: The Good Bahu.
The reasons behind the label are as follows, however strange.
I had lived alone in Bad Bad Bombay for five long years, worked in offices where we thought nothing about holding edit meets in pubs, mostly came back home around the same time as the milkman on weekends and despite that opted to stay in a joint family in Delhi after I got married. And horror of horrors, it was a vegetarian Jain joint family.
Aur sabse badi baat yeh hai ki, R2I and Old Pal stayed with their parents, never drank anything stronger than Coke (no jokes here, okay?) and had arranged marriages and despite that they couldn't adjust to their joint families or MILs . So I had to be either the yes mummyji type good bahu variety apparently only seen in Ekta Kapoor serials or a complete doormat.
During the illuminating chat where I found out this excellent side to myself, R2I was appalled by my in-laws' ostrich like attitude to non-veg . "But it compromises your freedom," she wrote in bold.
"Well not if you managed to eat everything from Prawn Koliwada to Tangdi Kabab everytime you dined out," I said.
"What if someone spotted you?" asked Old Pal, always the careful planning type.
"We'd decided to deal Ostrich with Ostrich and would've crossed the bridge only when we came to it, thankfully we never did,"I countered.
"Kam se kam you could have asked them to keep anda at home,"they said.
"But why? It was their home. I started keeping enough anda to feed an army the moment I shifted into mine," I replied.
That wasn't enough to control the curiosity of course. "So what do you do now when your in laws come over?"
"Simple. I just eat up all the salami in the fridge and go on a detox diet of ghia and toori for a month."
"And you still get along fairly well with your mother-in-law..." R2I answered her own question in utter wonder, before adding, "You must be doing whatever they tell you to do, yaar."
Frankly, that's the part I never get. That it surprises many people who have known me for a while that I get along with MIL. Well not in a 'let's go shopping together and have lunch afterwards,' manner, that's with my mum. Let's just say if my in-laws, who've been here for the last one and half month, were to extend their stay by another month, I wouldn't exactly be hitting the roof in hysteria. I may just suddenly increase going out for a fish heavy lunch.
When it comes to my relationship with the in-laws, food is the only area that is surrounded in a haze of white lies and unposken assumptions. They're pure vegetarians and I am purely non vegetarian. When I got married, they (or rather MIL) assumed I'd given up non-veg. Why don't ask me, considering her son wasn't exactly a vegetarian out of home. Since in the initial years, we chose to live with them, I went along with the charade because outside the house, I lived exactly the way I had in Bombay. I ate burger-shurger and tikka-shikka, I partied, I worked late and no eyebrows were ever raised if I said I was working late and wouldn't be home before 10. There was the standard Delhi parent concern, yes, but no scorn. Oh, I did feel stifled sometime and I did hate everything sometimes but never enough to rebel because frankly, there was nothing to rebel against, except an overdose of paranthas, ghee and affection.
MIL and mine is a relationship founded successfully on a desire to be nice to each other and those white lies. Nine years down the line, I'm sure everyone can see through the lies but it still remains an unspoken area. Everything else about the relationship is truly the stuff that Hindi film dialogue writers can make a happy family drama out of.
Some of my friends like R2I, Old Pal and few others see it as compromising on my individuality, freedom and abracadabra but sadly, since I do not seem to have a single feminist bone in my deplorable body I fail to see it like that. The way I see it is simple. I'm not missing out on anything in my life. So why jump the gun? Why try and complicate happiness, care and love when you are getting a lot of it in return?
Some of my friends like R2I, Old Pal and few others see it as compromising on my individuality, freedom and abracadabra but sadly, since I do not seem to have a single feminist bone in my deplorable body I fail to see it like that. The way I see it is simple. I'm not missing out on anything in my life. So why jump the gun? Why try and complicate happiness, care and love when you are getting a lot of it in return?
You're fooling them, especially your very trusting MIL, a friend said to me long ago. Really? She knows I'm short tempered, I hate ostentatious Jain weddings, that I would rather wear silver than diamond jewellary and never develop a taste for thande thande jamun with salt. They both know I hate drying clothes out of the machine, can be lost in a book for hours and stay up nights staring into the computer. They also know I can shout at maids and autowalas, that I rarely visit temples and would rather read a magazine than watch Baaghban on TV with them. I wonder if it would still be called fooling.
Like I finally said to a very persistant R2I, who I'm afraid is considering me her pet project in India, what works for someone may not work for another. Somehow, this has worked out for me. And there are other elements at work here than just the fact that I do not eat non veg when they are around. Why is that so hard for someone to fathom?
29 comments:
hi, i don't comment here often. but this post made me want to say I really admire your attitude. though i may not agree with the part you keep unknown, what you said abt compromising a bit so you get a lot in return - 100% with you. i think sometimes we tend to get carried away with the feminism bit.
Kodi's Mom: Thank you. Like I said, to each her own :). And I don't think we get carried away with feminism. We simply confuse it.
Have been reading you for long and disappointed at this pathetic attempt to justify what I can only call a lie, white or black. What prompted this? Prava
Anon: Nothing prompted this. I blog about anything that comes to my mind when I feel like it. It's rather simple actually. As for what you call a pathetic attempt, well, I can't stop you from being outraged, can I? Go right ahead :)
Well, i think there is nothing white or black about this. Why should somethings be spoken aloud if they are only going to create friction?
I am normally very comfortable in jeans and tops but when I am at my in-laws place, I wear salwar-kameez! If I wear salwar-kameez for 2-3 days, the sky is not going to fall. My M-I-L is aware that I don't exactly wear these clothes in Bengaluru but she is happy that at least when she is around I am dressed traditionally. So whats the harm?
If it really doesn't bother you, what's the harm? Sometimes individualism can be taken too far. And we live among other people. Can't always do things our way.
Kahini
My daughter is introducing me to the internet and bookmarks interesting articles for me to read. 35 years ago, I faced a similar situation as you, in reverse. I married within the community but into a family that couldn't do without their daily mutton and egg. In my house, we didn't even mention mutton, forget about cooking it. Few months after my marriage I learnt to cook mutton because I realised my husband's father actually wanted to eat bahu ke haath ka khana. It's a different story that I not just washed my hands but in the early days even took a bath after cooking what to me was something really horrible to touch. But I did it because it created a bond. They felt so happy that a bahu who herself was a vegetarian would take the trouble to learn and cook this for them. Like you I kept one secret. Nobody knew how furiously I would scrub myself clean later. Take care.
-- Manpreet
Can't really comment, as the nearest I've come to dealing with in-laws is my meeting with the (now ex) BF's parents. They seemed to like me, but i was VERY nervous meeting them, cos I don't create a very good first impression with people of that generation (my friend told me that her granma didn't like me cos I was "too independent").
But I think you're stance on the matter is right. I think I'd do the same. I *think*.
smart bahu!
ps: are you the one that wrote a cook-book?
Madhura: Exactly! In my case it's food instead of clothes :)
Kahini: It doesn't bother me much anymore honestly. A strained relationship would trouble me more.
Manpreet: Welcome. And I am really touched by that comment. Thank you.
Sonia: I never thought that I'd do this before marriage. I'd have probably lkeft a comment here saying 'ýou're losing out on your individuality or something :)
Phatichar: Book? har har har...
Well, my own parents think i'm weird and whenever they visit, I have to change my whole lifestyle, so...
Hey, way to go!What they don't know won't hurt them. This is not lying, it's diplomacy. Good girl. More wimmen like you and that depressingly regressive Ekta Kapoor would shut shop, yay!
I actually love the title. Sounds like a Kung Fu movie with you in the lead.
Sonia: hmmm...
Rupagulab: Oh come on, I'm apparently rather regressive myself. Maybe I should join Ekta K and make munny
Barkha: LOL! That was the idea behind the title. Wish I could do graphics.
Regressive? You? Just because you eat veg food at home when your in-laws are in town? What a foolish notion! BTW, Paul McCartney will love you!!!
Rupa!!! Anyone but Paul McCartney. Ugh
Funny, this post showed up on my feedreader only today.
Sometimes I feel guilty about such deceit (is that too strong a word?), at other times I feel they'd prefer not to know a few things (alcohol, and my folks - in this case). Then I decide to let things be, for now.
shub: the best is to let it be. but that's my take
Now that I can comment, may I say that your in-laws thought I was so CUTE?! LOL
Subs
well you are in you know. and they never saw you with straight hair :-p
i cannot imagine someone not getting what you are saying! to me it looks like a great way of handling the whole relationship and everything that comes with it!
no relationship is based on complete honesty and seriously there are far more important issues at hand than what we eat or wear which am sure your in-laws ALSO realise and respect! :)
i do that too! when my MIL is in town, i let her rule the house and she knows i am no pushover, but will let her do things her way as long as they dont come in my way!
and many people have told me i am the Good bahu in a condescening tone and i just cant fathom, why?!
great post!
cheers!
abha (fellow good bahu!)
I get along with my MIl too, but in my case I'm sure she's the one bending some. I appreciate it. Nice post Rash!
Abha: Jai ho. Let's go attend some satsang sessions to keep up the image
Alpha: dhanyabad. happy to see u back!
I totally admire you for your balanced approach to dealing with this. Though must add, credit goes to them as well for letting you be yourself in other ways -- the stuff that really matters -- working hours, read a magazine, do your thing. that's far more important than veg food, i think. and that's why you guys get along so well.
yumma mamma: Right. Absolutely.
Nice post!
Well, I do like my MIL but as u mite say "stretching the feminist attitude", i have few questions which lead me baffled :) My IL's are pure jains (no mention of onion,garlic at home) whereas i am a fanatic for those things. So by thot of stayin in a joint-family, these Q pop-up in my head...What if i love the non-jain dishes which i make by my own hands instead of outside dishes? dishes which i would love to make at "my" home? Compromise. What if i do not have any sibling to take care of my parents and i want to take care of them by having them live closeby and cook for them as well? Will they also have to compromise on a very basic entity like food (JUST coz they gave birth to a female instead of a son and decided to be satisfied with an only girl child)?
Anon: Thanks. The questions are damn valid. Ok now I sound like a lecturer on a podium but haan there are still some prejudices trhat do not make any sense
Post a Comment