Wednesday, August 20, 2008

Jai ho...HO HO HO!

Hello darlings!

As you can see from the headline only, have gone slightly batty. Tis a result of this early morning read in the venerable The Hindu by an honored (with Capital H) gentleman called Abhimanyu Singh. You see, Mr Singh didn't like Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na. My friend's older sis didn't like it too. Too college type, she smirked. As for my college type niece, she doesn't like anything without Hrithik Roshan in it. Zimble.

Mr Singh of course doesn't go for such facetious excoozes. Especially after he thought Abbas Tyrewala was a Godard in the making. So what does he do after being sadly mistaken in this assumption? He makes my day and writes a long article in The Hindu on Jaane Tu...being a paean to patriarchy, stereotyping women, etc.

Here's a sample: "Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na" only serves to strengthen the codes of patriarchy that have dominated the representation and subsequent construction of masculine and feminine identity in cinema `. by disturbing the symbolic order of patriarchy in order to motivate audience assent to its restoration'. Here, that can be seen in Jay's initial reluctance to accept the three diktats of manhood prescribed by his father and later fulfilling them.' For the whole piece of cake, go here.

Wondering why nobody told him it was simply a nice, timepass Hindi film?

12 comments:

Sonia said...

Oh. My. God!

This guy needs a life!

Hornswoggler said...

Sonia: Hee hee, he does!

Lakshmi said...

lol..analyst in the wrong profession

Hornswoggler said...

Lakshmi: Doesn't it remind you of SCM? :p

Ravi Kumar said...

Hi Rash, ravi here. Liked the humor element in your writing. And also saw some travel blogs that you browse often. Bumped into your blog through saurabh's blog. Please let me know your opinion
Hi I too started a blog on India backpacker:
www.lonebackpacker.blogspot.com

Hornswoggler said...

Ravi: Thank you Ravi. Will check it out soon.

Lakshmi said...

yeah..completely..

rupagulab said...

Hey! Enjoyed your piece on Coorg. Been there many years ago, and you brought lovely memories back!

Mama - Mia said...

i need a dictionary, quick!! :p

man! i hate it when people try to dissect every movie with a view that it should hve been classic! and people who like to pretend that if the movie is a serious tearjerker or leaves you clues, it good cinema!!

i have started saying shamlessly that i really enjoyed race!! it was a thriller i liked it! big deal!!

and i looorrveee Imran!! :D

cheers!

abha

Hornswoggler said...

Rupa: Thankoo. Come here. I believe our ideas of stressfree holidays are the same. We shall remove ourselves to Coorg.

Abha: Yes, shameless women unite. I luwwwwwww Race, Imran, Farhan, Shah Rukh and even georgette heyer ;-p

Pallavi said...

did not like that movie that much.. :(

Hornswoggler said...

pallavi: yes, whatever but did it require analysis? :p